Showing posts with label Holy Fool. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Holy Fool. Show all posts

Wednesday, 14 August 2013

A Pop Music Emergency: From Pallor to Applause


By Laurence Ross and Meghan Vicks


The voice is one akin to the automated airline intercom telling you to secure the mask to your face and breathe normally in order to begin the flow of oxygen. “Thank you for your cooperation during this pop music emergency,” she posts.

This voice is admittedly calmer than the one a mere seven hours before: “A POP MUSIC EMERGENCY IS UNDERWAY 911,” and “911 SUMMON THE MONSTER TROUPES.” Or her post on Saturday: “Wanna grab some shovels and fuck up some hackers?”

Applause: (from the Latin applaudere, to strike upon, clap), primarily the expression of approval by clapping of hands; generally any expression of approval.

What exactly is a state of emergency, let alone a “pop music emergency”?

A state of emergency is a period when the exception to the rule takes over – the state of exception. Normal order is suspended, and what is usually outlawed takes control precisely in order to save the system that is under attack or corrupted, that is under unbearable tension or friction. It turns out (as it often does) that the system is dependent upon that which it normally excludes, outlaws, taboos.

Lady Gaga announces a state of emergency on 12 August 2013, and there emerges “Applause,” accompanied by thejester Gaga-Pierrot. “Applause” and Gaga-Pierrot are thus positioned as the exception to the rule that has come to rule, as the exclusion-from-the-system that is necessary to restore the system, as the outlaw that has come to save us from a corrupted rule.

The questions arise: what is this system that we need saving from? What has caused this state of emergency?


The custom of applauding is doubtless as old and as widespread as humanity, and the variety of its forms is limited only by the capacity for devising means of making a noise. Among civilized nations, however, it has at various times been subject to certain conventions.

Of course, this is a “pop music emergency.” Applause aside, pop music does seem to be in a state of emergency at the moment. There seems to be a crisis mounting that, however overblown it might seem to those on the outskirts of the skirmish, is bleeding across territories (take Jay-Z at the PACE gallery for example). Gaga emerges from the Chateau Marmont in Los Angeles looking like the victim of a mugging in her Pierrot make-up and, indeed, harassment has occurred.

Pop music seems an easy target for criticism, if criticism’s aim is to take aim, to fire upon, to maim or kill. Because the nature of pop culture is to be of the moment, there seems to be the assumption that the products of pop culture are disposable, are garbage, are waste. Perhaps people believe pop music can’t be “good” music because the assumption is that the artist isn’t really an artist, that the artist does not really exist, that there is no such thing as a pop music artist – the songs, the albums, the images, the music videos are the products of teams, of managers, of producers, of marketers. And a product intended for (mass) consumption. Perhaps people believe this type of product is necessarily “bad,” is rotten before it even hits the shelves.

In truth, the conversations of what is “good” and what is “bad” are tiring. Gaga seems weary of such criticisms and conversations well, with the makeup of “Applause” hacked and leaked across the Internet, her make-up in smears amidst her sheets. ‪#‎StopTheDramaStartTheMusic And if the critic is trying to play the judge, to moderate what is worth listening to and what is not, to parse out what deserves our attention and what does not, then the critic’s gavel is one made out of crystal – an object precious to some, pretty to others, and petty to others still, but an object that shatters regardless if used to bash. Is the critic’s role to silence some and let others speak? We hope not. We are far more interested in seeing what reflects in/on the work than naming the work as “good” or “bad”; we are far more interested in seeing how the various surfaces of pop culture lean against one another, intersect; we are far more interested in the pattern of light pop music – or any other cultural spectacle – makes on the wall when we hold the gavel just so.

Thus the Romans had a set ritual of applause for public performances, expressing degrees of approval: snapping the finger and thumb, clapping with the flat or hollow palm, waving the flap of the toga.

So into this pop music emergency “Applause” emerges, hand in hand with the jester Gaga-Pierrot – the latest incarnation of Gaga’s trickster, which is abundantly fitting as tricksters, by their very nature, are exclusions from systems, exceptions to the rules, border breakers, outcasts, outlaws, out-of-bounds, outside. Gaga-Pierrot and “Applause” are the antidote to the poison that has made a culture of dull, unimaginative, and elitist naysayers, whose knee-jerk reaction to any manifestation of pop culture (especially pop music, celebrity, and reality-TV culture) is to sneer and snub, to tear down, to urgently and stridently shriek THAT’S NOT ART, to proclaim creative risks as “fame whoring,” to constantly publish articlesthat literally say no more than here’s another celebrity failing at art, to hissLady Gaga is a joke! In their scorn, they don’t realize how right they are.

Gaga turns the joke, the joker, the jester Pierrot whose new theme song is “Applause,” into that which will rescue us from this pop music emergency. After all, a joke is intended to break a strain, a tension; Schiller defines comedy as something that inspires “freedom of the soul”; and Kant insists on the therapeutic nature of laughter – the “sudden emotion arising from the sudden transformation of a strained expectation into nothing.” And, perhaps, in the face of strained expectation, in the face of “what will she do next,” in the face of the “Lady No More Gaga” headlines she has predicted since “Paparazzi,” Gaga paints her face white, simultaneously the visible absence of color and the base of all color, so that sudden emotions of color may arise. The figure of the jester Pierrot allows Gaga to say, You dismissed me as a joke again and again; now I’ve come to save you precisely as the joke you dismissed.

When Christianity became fashionable the customs of the theatre were transferred to the churches.

Gaga-Pierrot doesn’t rescue with reasoned argument (she’s not interested in the critic’s “right or wrong” – this kind of question has become banal and meaningless), but with song and bodied performance. The lyrics of “Applause” make bodily demands of its listeners – asRoland points out, the lyrics guide listeners through movements (“put your hands up, make em touch,” “make it real loud”) that ultimately generate a ritual coming together of community. The song takes on flesh as the audience applauds – indeed the song is left hanging, incomplete without the audience’s applause just as Gaga-Pierrot lives and loves for the applause, and means nothing without it. But it’s not just the song “Applause” and the jester Gaga-Pierrot that come to life in this ritual: we, the spectators, the citizens of pop culture, are born this way too. This audience participation has been part of her act from the very beginning, when we are not so much asked but told to just dance. Gaga and audience are continually in a give-and-give relationship: we sing to one another: “I’m your biggest fan, I’ll follow you until you love me.”

One of the main rules that Gaga-Pierrot breaks to bring us together is the notion that coming together requires a physical proximity. Instead, she builds community upon 0s and 1s, across the Internet’s constellations, via digital profiles and online presences. “Send us your videos of you and your friends dancing at school [...] AT HOME IS OK TOO [...] WORK IS ALSO FINE,” she commands, and later: “Let me see your #APPLAUSECoverSelfie !” And the citizens respond, in droves:





Now the image of Gaga-Pierrot has gone viral in a worldwide digital drag performance. Now “Applause” has taken flesh and form and movement infinitely across the world. We’re reminded of something Devin O’Neill wroteafter first seeing Gaga’s commercialfor Google Chrome: “You can call it crass commercialism, but I can wander around my neighborhood and go days without experiencing the kind of humanity she communicated through that television commercial.” There is real humanity emerging via the workings of Gaga-Pierrot and “Applause.” And the community of monsters has shifted into a community of clowns, jesters, jokers, tricksters.

Eusebius (Hist. Eccl. vii. 30) says that Paul of Samosata encouraged the congregation to applaud his preaching by waving linen cloths, and in the 4th and 5th centuries applause of the rhetoric of popular preachers had become an established custom.

When the white flag is waved, the emergency has ended, or at the very least is ebbing. The idea of the white flag is the idea that it is time to resolve, to reconcile, to construct something new out of the opposing sides. There is something about the coming together, the joining of hands and the clapping of hands that is sacramental, a communal act, a spiritual communion. Synchronized movement is sacrament.

Here, Gaga’s embodiment of the jester Pierrot partakes in the mythology of the fool in its various manifestations: not only the sad clown Pierrot, but also the holy fools of the Russian tradition (юродивый, yurodiviy), and the wise fools of Shakespeare. Pierrotis often the fool who is always the butt of everyone’s jokes, but who nevertheless remains trusting of others. Likewise, the Russian holy fool creates a spectacle of degradation and debasement that invites the criticism of others, which allows him to draw attention to the world’s own debasement and pray for those who abuse him. Shakespeare’s fools are objectified sources of laughter, so far outside the cultural (and critical) norms as to be shrugged off as innocuous (if incessantly speaking) dolts. And it is precisely the role of the fool, of being viewed as a less-than species to ignore, that allows them to get away with murder/a murderous truth, to speak with the most meaning. However, in order to comprehend these truths, these realities, the audience must be able to trust in the fool, to be open and available to hear the words that are so plainly spoken. In all three manifestations of the fool, these figures are not destroyed by criticism; rather, they turn criticism into something beautiful: faith in humanity despite its endless taunting (Pierrot), salvation (holy fool), and enlightenment (Shakespeare’s fools). Gaga as the fool gives us all three and waits/lives for our return action – to keep the relationship going, echoing back and forth. She sings so that we may sing so that she may sing; we applaud so that she may applaud so that we may applaud.

I live for the Applause, plause.
I stand here waiting for you to bang the gong.

Author bios:
Laurence Ross holds an MFA in Creative Writing from the University of Alabama. He formerly served as the Creative Nonfiction Editor for the Black Warrior Review and now lives in New Orleans where he writes for Pelican Bomb, a regional publication dedicated to the Louisiana arts community. He is currently at work on a book-length project concerning the lives and deaths of our cultural spectacles/specters.

Meghan Vicks is co-editor of Gaga Stigmata. She holds a Ph.D. in Comparative Literature, and is currently turning her dissertation Narratives of Nothing in Twentieth-Century Literature into her first monograph. She teaches Russian literature, language, and culture courses at the University of Colorado, Boulder.



Click here to follow Gaga Stigmata on Twitter.
Click here to “like” Gaga Stigmata on Facebook.

Sunday, 22 May 2011

Holy Fool • Holy Scheiße

By Meghan Vicks 

The following is a companion piece to STIGMATAVISION 1: Holy Fool. 


Cause it’s a hard life, with love in the world.
And I’m a hard girl, loving me is like chewing on pearls.

When Lady Gaga sings “I’m just a holy fool” in “Judas,” she succinctly articulates the status she now occupies. Meaning, the role of the “holy fool” fittingly describes Gaga’s aesthetic and, especially, how the public reacts to her. Traditionally, the holy fool embodies the most squalid and debased of men, and, at the same time, the most godlike and perfect of men; what is most glorified is present in what is most sullied. Likewise, as we’ve written ad nauseum here at GS (we believe in honoring our vomit, too), Lady Gaga is another such figure who places sacred and meaningful aspirations in the most dismissed and illegitimate of today’s cultural figures, the pop starlet.

As artists, we are eternally heartbroken.


But the “holy fool” may also perfectly describe this phenomenon of academic and creative studies on Lady Gaga, which, in the first place, seek to take Gaga seriously as a subject of academic discourse (that is, we bring what is often regarded as the trash of culture [e.g. pop music and performance] into the space of high culture [academia]), and, in the second place, aim to challenge our own epistemological foundations, to reconsider what legitimate scholarship looks and reads like, just as Lady Gaga has forced us to reconsider (once again) what legitimate art looks and sounds likes. And as Lady Gaga’s spectacle, like the Holy Fool’s, often ignites people to outrage, to throw stones at such a figure who would dare to challenge the lines between the sacred and the profane, so we here at Gaga Stigmata provoke our readers to lash out just by engaging in an academic project that studies Lady Gaga. Stones are thrown from both sides of the line: by those who think we’re reading “too much” into Lady Gaga, who think we should just enjoy her project for what it is (meaningless but fun! pop music, they say); and by those who think we’re misappropriating theory, sullying that sacred thought by applying it to Lady Gaga’s hairbow or her video for “Born This Way.” These are the ones who advise us to use our talents for something that “matters,” or who tell us how disappointed they are that all this energy is being spent on a figure like Lady Gaga. How many times have we been offered the philosopher’s straightjacket? We’re writing our way to Bedlam, sullying with glitter the Ivory Tower, or spoiling the lighthearted pop party with our persnickety analyses that unearth much more in “Just Dance” than a simple party song.


Do you know the feeling, when your heart is so hurt, that you could feel the blood dripping?

However, we maintain that people’s reactions to Lady Gaga and our readers’ reactions to Gaga Stigmata say a great deal about how challenging and meaningful a figure like Lady Gaga actually is, and tell us much about what academic study like GS does: that is, both Lady Gaga and Gaga Stigmata make us uncomfortable precisely because they dare our epistemologies to uphold themselves, they challenge what we know about culture, knowledge, art, politics, gender, academics, music, etc. They threaten our precious borders, forcing us to encounter the abject – that impossible and unthinkable ambiguity that resides on the outside, in “the place where meaning collapses” (Kristeva 2). Gaga and GS bring us face-to-face with “a ‘something’ that [we] do not recognize as a thing. A weight of meaninglessness, about which there is nothing insignificant, and which crushes [us]. On the edge of nonexistence and hallucination, or a reality that, if [we] acknowledge it, annihilates [us]” (ibid). So we revolt (vomit), rage against their abject that so threatens our knowable world.


Of course, such reactions speak volumes about the public’s expectations of the pop star and academic discourse, but they are also, at times, a kind of sin. People self-righteously judge, call names, wish misfortune upon, condemn, censor, and lament both Gaga and GS. They throw stones, but do not pause to consider that maybe these stones are part of the point.

I don’t want the 5 dollars in your pocket, I want your soul.

A spectacle – either in pop music or in academic discourse – that forces people to react, that challenges basic assumptions, that merges the sacred and the profane. It is in this way that both Lady Gaga and Gaga Stigmata are reminiscent of the holy fool. For he resides precisely in the neverland between the sacred and the profane: he is the spectacle that performs against a Janus-faced background of official pomp of the state/church (//s academia) and ribald culture of folk laughter (//s Gaga). This notion of performance is central to both the hagiography of the holy fool, and to the popular understanding of the figure: his foolishness was often seen as his choice, as a willful acceptance of humiliation and suffering. His folly was therefore a deliberate spectacle of self-debasement, an intended kenotic performance through which his self was emptied and relinquished for the sake of the salvation of others.

The effects of this spectacle were many in form and single in intent – to variously bring the spectators closer to the divine. One desired effect was to lead the audience directly into sin, to encourage their taunts and abuses of the fool. The fool would then ask God’s forgiveness for their sins: “The ‘madman’ prays for forgiveness for his fellow ‘madmen’” (Murav 25). Another effect was to unmask and stage the degraded state of humanity, and its concurrent need for redemption. Again, the fool’s performance and spectacle comes to the forefront. A third effect was to provide a site of resistance against official culture in the figure of the fool. In all, the holy fool’s inverting and inverted figure and performance do not simply intend to demonstrate the relativity of existence, but endeavor to draw the sacred to the debased human world.


We are not just Art for Michelangelo to carve, he can’t rewrite the agro of my furied heart.

In the past few months leading up to the release of her sophomore album Born This Way, Gaga’s been repeatedly saying, “let the cultural baptism begin.” It’s time, she tells us, to clean culture of its sins, and Gaga herself is the kenotic figure through which this will happen. Like the holy fool whose spectacle reveals society’s degradation and actively affects its spectators, drawing them in and forcing them to react to the degraded culture embodied in the holy fool, ultimately rousing them to sin against him so that he can pray for their redemption, so Gaga provokes and challenges us, causes many of us to sin against her precisely so that the culture as a whole may be baptized – emptied of its sins through Gaga, who forces their release upon her figure. She invites us to stone her: rage against Gaga, so that she can cry for us. Empty your hatred upon her, so that she can pray for your redemption. The point is, the stones are necessary for the baptism to take place – the cultural baptism cannot occur if people keep hidden their various sins, prejudices, and hatreds. All these must be purged (vomit, again) in order for cultural cleansing.

I want the deepest, darkest, sickest parts of you that you are afraid to share with anyone because I love you that much.

We perform the role of the holy fool as well, finding the highest, most sacred meaning in this free bitch who makes millions singing pop music and trotting her bare ass all over creation. Our writings threaten some readers, forcing them to sin. And we shed tears. It therefore happens that stigmata of Gaga’s wounds have begun to bleed through our writings, strangle our words. Gaga Stigmata is shedding its italics, becoming literal, corporeal stigmata. We embody her – our criticism takes on her flesh and tears; we vomit her puke.

Like Kate in STIGMATAVISION 1, we break out in Gaga’s rash. It’s physiological, not just mental, this reaction/relationship to Gaga. This art/criticism makes us anxious precisely because it forces us to dress in our former wedding attire and confront those ideas/people/ideals to which we were once wedded and now can no longer be. We’ve evolved, and the blood spilling from our words and onto our wedding dresses is proof of the growing pains.


We work, so maniacally, to reconsider and revise what academic writing does and looks like, while loving so sincerely (like a spouse, maybe) the academy. We also love Lady Gaga, so much that when she bleeds on stage we feel blood soaking through our shirt, replacing the ink in our pens as we write our research. But we remember that love is like a brick, which is a lot like a stone – it can also build a house or sink a dead body.


Prejudice is a disease. And when they come for you, or refuse your worth, I will be ready for their stones. I belong to you.

So throw your stones: give us this day, our daily Scheiße. We’ll take it to the Electric University, light it up in those ivory halls. Let the academic baptism begin.


Click here to follow Gaga Stigmata on Twitter.
Click here to “like” Gaga Stigmata on Facebook.

Saturday, 21 May 2011

STIGMATAVISION 1: HOLY FOOL

By Kate Durbin

Compare hotel prices and find the best deal - HotelsCombined.com
Compare hotel prices and find the best deal - HotelsCombined.com
Twitter Delicious Facebook Digg Stumbleupon Favorites More