Showing posts with label DADT. Show all posts
Showing posts with label DADT. Show all posts

Tuesday, 26 July 2011

Traductor, Traditore: (Un)translating Born This Way’s Duplicitous Message

By Samantha Cohen

It’s taken a long time for me to respond to “Born This Way.” It took a long time for me to watch the video, even. The first time I heard the song, I had to close its window before it ended. Oh Gaga, I thought. No.

Maybe it is silly, embarrassing even, to have such a prolonged emotional response to a pop song. To be actually saddened. But in the bio-deterministic world of mainstream media, Gaga had been an anti-essentialist beacon, beaming into the living rooms of, like, all U.S. families. In a world where female pop stars are packaged to be palatable, commoditized and literally defined by the gaze, Gaga’s art and fashion said fuck the gaze and fuck gazing into mirrors, even. Invent an identity. Invent another one. Become who you want to be and then become who you want to be and then become who you want to be again.

My love for Gaga had been based on her performative assertion of performance as identity and it broke suddenly and crushingly with three words: Born this way. I don’t get to love a lot of things in this world and so I hold on fiercely to the things I do. Lady Gaga was the only contemporary mainstream pop artist I was able to love and now what.

I still have complicated feelings, but I’m ready, I think, to work through them, here. It was Meghan Vicks’ article on Gaga as trickster that sparked a bit of hope toward the reignition of my Gaga love. What proceeds will be an argument that “Born This Way” marks Gaga’s self-outing as a trickster figure and that in “Born This Way,” she uses her trickster status to further the cause of gay rights. It will be, too, a personal attempt to redeem Gaga, an elaborate excuse-making for an artist I want badly to love.

***

So, trickster: Coyote, Raven, Prometheus, Loki, Eshu, Hermes, Mercurius. Et fucking al. All mythologies, all cultures, have a trickster figure, and at the site of any change in the social fabric, there s-he is. Trickster is shape-shifter, gender-transcender, a two-spirited seducer. Trickster embodies both sides of any binary opposition. Trickster is culture hero and amoral jokester. S-he is sacred and hilarious, ridiculous and godly, good and evil. Do I need to go on to convince you that Trickster is Gaga?

Okay but what I do need to convince you of, maybe, still, is that Gaga identifies herself as Trickster in the “Born This Way” video. So here: The video opens on a pink-triangle-contained Gaga with legs up where antlers might be, an animal (but still human) Gaga, a between-genders Gaga high-heeled and bearded.


This Gaga is revealed to have two heads and two faces, symbolizing Trickster’s dual nature. Gaga’s second face tells us a creation myth. A creation myth that breeds both good and evil. Wherever there’s a creation story, there Trickster is.

Plus, Trickster is able always to descend to the realm of the dead – to play around and shift things down there. At various points in the video, Gaga enters a sort of underground meat locker where a dead guy dwells. Gaga herself’s in death drag. We know it’s death drag because while the actual dead guy’s catatonic, Gaga’s dancing vigorously, chest-beating, even. She’s physically manipulating the dead guy, presumably for her own ends. Gaga’s down in the death realm for a shifting.

***

But so here’s the thing about Trickster: Trickster’s ends are always the ends of creation, of social change. Trickster is thief, outlaw, destroyer, and ultimately, creator. Trickster uses the Lorde-ian “master’s tools” to dismantle his superstructure, all while entertaining and enchanting, distracting and seducing the fuck out of him. Or H-I-M. Coyote, Loki, Anansi, and Prometheus, for example, all charmed their ways into stealing fire from the gods in order to bring the sun, moon, and stars to the people of their respective cultures.

Trickster uses the language of the dominant culture to get the job done.

“Born This Way” is essentialist, for sure – but Gaga knows that essentialism’s what gay-basher bullies are able to hear, what those in power to change the gay rights situation know how to respond to: There is no other way. You were born this way.

In his book Trickster Makes The World, Lewis Hyde argues that Tricksters are “joint-disturbers” (256) – that Trickster pinpoints the joints of any being, culture, or idea it plans to attack and, in a sense, lubes up these joints in order to move around the more solid pieces they connect, to slide them smoothly, smilingly, and reconnect them elsewhere. Trickster must fit easily into either side of the joint, must seduce both sides in order to slide them so smoothly. Gaga recognizes where the joint of the gay rights debate is, and she works that joint.

Gaga’s aware that U.S. gay rights hinge on proof (or at least belief) that homosexuality is biological. The rhetoric surrounding the U.S. gay rights debate has been, on the right side of the joint, that homosexuality is a sinful choice (God says), and, on the left side, that homosexuality is genetic, and therefore cannot be sinful, since it’s not a choice at all (Science says). “Born This Way” sides with the science of the left, functioning as an anthem self-assured enough to fill in any gaps the scientific studies might leave. Simultaneously, it challenges the right by bringing their God into its message and subtly questioning their faith in H-I-M: Gaga’s God makes no mistakes. Gaga’s God didn’t mess up in creating the gays.

***

Hyde claims that Trickster always serves as translator between two realms. The realms between which Gaga translates in “Born This Way” are actually not the realms of the right and the left; they are the realms of born-this-way gay rights activists and anti-essentialist self-performers. While pro-gay equality and anti-gay equality sides of the argument are essentially speaking the same language (no choice vs. choice), we (queers, academics) are literally speaking a different language than those who seek proof of genetic gayness. We require a translator. And Hyde reminds us of the Italian saying, “traductor, traditore,” or, translator = traitor (264).

Signifying Monkey defeats his Lion oppressor using verbal tricks and witty discourse the Lion is unable to understand. Though Monkey is speaking Lion language, Monkey twists this language. Monkey uses symbolism and the Lion can only understand what is literal. Br’er Rabbit, too, despite being rabbit-sized, uses wit, trickery, and the invention of a new symbolism in order to dismantle the enslaving social rhetoric.

It’s important that, just as Signifying Monkey speaks in Lion language, Gaga doesn’t use academic jargon or the language of queer subcultures. Her litany of identities doesn’t include butch, boi, bear, or even queer. She is speaking the language that the dominant culture understands to be theirs.

One thing Gaga’s use of the language of the dominant culture enables her to do is insert the word “transgender” into the mainstream lexicon. Transgendered life, is what she says. LGBT has sort of just become code for “gay,” while its other initials get lost. The word transgendered is still underlined in red by MS Word’s spell check where I’m typing this.

***
   
Gaga’s creation myth is pretty clearly for us, the anti-essentialist self-performing ones, the academics, the artists, the queers. Who else cares about origin stories or the “multiverse” or mucus-y glittery cell division but the same freaks who care about performance as identity? And one way to read Gaga’s creation myth is as a form of extended justification, an apology for the essentialism to come. The final line of Gaga’s creation myth: “It seems easy, you imagine, to gravitate easily and unwaveringly towards good. But…how can I protect something so perfect, without evil?” As she says this, Gaga holds a machine gun, rendering actual the metaphorical master’s tool.

And when Gaga descends from her heavenly Mother Monster throne and enters the world of the song, she’s wearing (comparatively) subtle makeup and a bikini with dainty chains. Her attire is decidedly normal, pop-video appropriate. At first glance, it’s something Britney might wear. But Gaga’s prosthetic cheekbones and strange magazine glossiness exaggerate her normalcy in a way that lets us know that Gaga hasn’t walked away from her monsters, but is adopting the uniform of the mainstream in order to work inside the system, for us.

***

But so by showing us that she identifies as Gay Rights Trickster, Gaga invites us to look beyond the platitudinous words of her almost-parodically reductive anthem, or to look deeper into them. But then what is she saying beyond the seeming-essentialism?

First, the vaginas through which Gaga’s new race are birthed are made not only of shiny pink membrane, but also of black patent and glitter and silver chains, dissolving the boundary between nature and artifice. And, then! Post creation-myth, in the first shot of the dance floor, the dancers are hunched and shadowed to be shaped like uteri and ovaries.


We might miss this had the video not primed us (at least) twice already with ovary/uterus shapes during the creation story, but since we’re primed, we totally see it. And what it suggests is that we can form ourselves into our own uterus-and-ovaries, into our own self-birthing centers. That we can curl in on ourselves and gestate, any time we need to, and be reborn.

The factory rows of Gaga heads, inchoate and waxy, suggest that there are multiple possible selves for all of us, that we simply have to call on one of our own partly-formed baby heads, to shake it awake and wash it off, in order to be new. I love this.

***

I’ve convinced myself now that Gaga has not had an essentialist conversion. But I still have tangled feelings about whether it is okay to put such a strong essentialist message out into so much of the world. I’m pretty sure most people who hear “Born This Way,” or even watch the video, will not see past the apparent biodeterminism. Isn’t it destructive to tell gay kids, or “orient-made” (I won’t go into this term’s issues here) kids that the have no choice in who they become, that they are victims of the circumstances of their births?

But then, shortly after Gaga’s Prime Rib of America speech, DADT was repealed. Months after the release of “Born This Way,” gay marriage was legalized in New York. On June 24 just after New York legalized gay marriage, Gaga tweeted “I can’t stop crying. We did it, kids.” Maybe this is not self-puffery but just…somewhat accurate. We could ask whether these huge systematic changes are worth the propagating of an essentialist message, but I think a better question is, is there another way to create change? Or do we need this trickstery use of (which is also a propagation of) the dominant language, even if that language is harmful?

I don’t find “Born This Way” inspiring or beautiful. What I wish the whole world would watch instead is the scene in Paris is Burning where two joyful-looking transwomen frolic on the beach singing, “I am what I am / I am my own creation!” But what does this accomplish, social change-wise? 65 million people have watched the “Born This Way” video on YouTube alone. Paris is Burning, I think, is relegated mostly to the academy, or to queer living rooms only.

Angela Carter wrote that “a free woman in an unfree society will be a monster.” Gaga extends this monster-ness to all of the disenfranchised, the bullied, and the pushed-out who are dancing in 5-inch heels and hair dye (or in bowties and suspenders, or in A-shirts and Dickies). And maybe part of the monster quality is that we monsters can’t speak in our own language if we want to be taken seriously by the dominant culture, if we want to create big systemic change. Monsters have to skew, to craft, to seduce. Gaga, as self-appointed Monster Representative to the dominant culture, must be Trickster. We can go on speaking our language in our queer living rooms. We can create spaces for monster discourse and monster love. But if we want equal rights, we need a Trickster representative.

Before “Born This Way” begins Gaga tells us to “Put (our) paws up.” Not our hands. Our hands are for holding our lovers, for cutting friends’ hair and watering plants. Our hands are too pure for this kind of work. No, for Trickster work, we need our paws – our Monkey paws, our monster paws.

Author Bio:
Samantha Cohen is a writer living behind the Scientology building in Los Angeles.  Her fiction can be found in PANK, Black Clock, Storyglossia, The New Orleans Review, and Mary Magazine.  She's teaching a class called Semiotics of Fashion in the Critical Studies program at CalArts this fall.

Click here to follow Gaga Stigmata on Twitter.
Click here to “like” Gaga Stigmata on Facebook.

Sunday, 6 March 2011

From "Alejandro" to "Born This Way," Dirge to Liberation

By Cheryl Helm

The following piece is the sixth in our series on Lady Gaga’s video for “Born This Way.” Click here for our previous analyses of the video.

Eight months ago, Lady Gaga released “Alejandro” to great hoopla over its religious imagery, and over its (apparent) similarities to Madonna’s “La Isla Bonita” (musically) and “Vogue” (choreographically). Now she’s gifted us with “Born This Way,” a film with far more expansive religious imagery, and whose main controversies are the graphic birth scenes and inevitable debate over whether the song is a Madonna knockoff of “Express Yourself” (musically) and “Vogue” (the spoken/rapped lyrics).

“Born This Way” is not a narrative sequel to “Alejandro” (as “Telephone” follows the narrative line of “Paparazzi”). Rather, when compared with “Alejandro,” “Born This Way” reveals major conceptual pivots in Gaga’s aesthetic, and dramatic evolution in her approaches to certain themes. The most notable evolutions between the two videos are found in Gaga’s depiction of female power figure(s) and protagonists, in the progression from a closed gay community to an open inclusive community, and in a seeming shift away from the treatment of religion solely as a means of social and political oppression to a more catholic spirituality as a source of solace and strength.

Compare, for example, how the communities of the two films are shot and introduced. “Alejandro” is shot in cold low lighting, which matches its tonal darkness that stems from being a grievously sad story set in a bleak militant dystopia where solace in any form is in very short supply. Soldiers march bearing emblems of the Holocaust and its horrific human toll, which, as we well know, was justified by institutionalized racism and homophobia.


In contrast, “Born This Way” is shot in warm low-light that simulates birthing environments. The dancers are seen kneeling, in preparation for their births into full-grown offspring of the Eternal Mother. It is as joyous and celebratory as “Alejandro” is sorrowful and elegiac. While “Born this Way” is a liberation birth dance, “Alejandro” is a dirge, and an angry one at that.


“Born This Way” is strikingly different from “Alejandro” in tone and subtext, but a more careful examination of common elements and character types reveals them to be companion pieces that signify a change in Gaga’s overall project.

Institutional Religion vs. Popular Spirituality
An important distinction between “Alejandro” and “Born This Way” lies Gaga’s depiction of religion and faith. To the extent that “Alejandro” is, in part, about faith and freedom, it is both springboard and study in contrast to the philosophy behind “Born This Way.” Whereas the faith of “Alejandro” serves as sanctuary, escape, and justification for oppression, the faith of “Born This Way” functions as respite, solace, and a catalyst for liberation. The faith of “Alejandro” deals in stasis and death; “Born This Way,” in life and rebirth.

“Alejandro” presents faith in the context of a specific religious institution, which is rigid, controlling, and oppressive. It is faith in doctrine; it is a faith in which the light of divinity has gone out. The iconography in “Alejandro” is explicitly Christian, and of the Catholic variety. Crosses, crucifixes, rosaries, and nuns serve up an abundance of controversy. This Christian imagery is accompanied by symbols of oppression. For instance, a helmeted soldier and Gaga-as-nun are strung up like puppets, signifying that religious faith is a kind of bondage (and not the fun kind) – a sardonic twist in a film laden with lots of sex but no pleasure.


In contrast, “Born This Way” depicts faith as affirmative – something that can be called upon as a source of strength and comfort. More importantly, perhaps, the faith here is independent of any explicit religion or doctrine. The video contains a plethora of religious/spiritual images, however they are nondenominational: eastern and esoteric imagery abound while the cross is used only sparingly. From the upright and inverted triangles replete in both political and esoteric meaning, to the Eternal Mother’s lotuses, butterflies, and Third Eye chakra, “Born this Way” signals a shift away from religion (e.g. the Catholic Church) to a more universal, dare we say “catholic” (katholikos) expression of faith. Lyrically, Gaga invokes God explicitly (God makes no mistakes) and implicitly (Capital HIM), not as a basis for oppression but a spiritual affirmation of one’s own inherent divinity.


Two Faces of Liberation
The driving narratives of both “Alejandro” and “Born This Way” is a quest for acceptance liberation, but from opening to closing shots, those quests take place in very different worlds, and seek opposing kinds of freedom. These differences are largely functions of Gaga’s evolving artistic/political intentions and messages in the two videos.

“Alejandro” was created in the context of the debate over Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell. Although the video never overtly addresses the issue, it is nonetheless an impassioned plea for the abolition of policies, regulations, and laws that discriminate against LGBTQ people. Institutional liberation requires the rejection of religious influence behind every homophobic law and policy. On the surface it appears to be a denial of faith, but what it really requires is a change in the way people exercise their faith.

“Born This Way” is the Gospel of Gaga, which advocates for self-actualized liberation: self-acceptance, self-respect, self-empowerment. To achieve it requires no institutional acquiescence, no defeat of personal opponents or bullies (in fact, there’s not a hint of any adversarial personal or institutional relationships). It is an act of faith to embrace ourselves with full belief that we are exactly as we were meant to be, whether we consider ourselves to be divinely created or not. It is an article of faith to say, “I am beautiful, I am perfect in my own way,” and walk by that faith, live by it.

What Gaga seeks in “Alejandro” is escape, not self-liberation. She uses religion to avoid dealing with her grief and her frustrated relationships. In “Born This Way” Gaga seeks to find and express the liberation that is already hers by birthright. The Gaga of “Alejandro” desperately looks outside herself for freedom in other people and things, and uses sex to force her way to acceptance by a group that doesn’t really want her. The Gaga of “Born This Way” seeks her freedom within, and shares the quest and celebration of this freedom with kindred folk.

The Goddess/Queen Archetype
“Born This Way” begins with a Creation Myth, a Gaga Genesis tale. The Eternal Mother is a figure of Light, giver of life, protector of her young. We first see the back of her head, bearing a face that evokes both Metropolis as well as the faces on her offspring. The opening sequence accompanying the narrative is among the most visually powerful in Gaga’s oeuvre, particularly the skyward turn toward G.O.A.T., where constellations form a pair of ovaries. There, the Eternal Mother is the womb, and the vaginal birth canal is an amber-lit translucent ramp. She is attended by a midwife, and flanked on both sides by dancers in soft shadows. Note the recurrent appearance of the letter “V” visually framed in different ways, which reinforces time and again that “No, I don’t have a penis. I have a vagina. Now watch me put it to work.”


Her nature is procreative. She is chained to her birthing throne, her hoof-like feet raised in stirrups, but is otherwise not confined or restricted. At the birth of evil, she herself is torn in two, the Evil Mother sitting atop a lightning bolt ziggurat, birthing twin skeletal figures and an AK-47 (I’ll see your machine gun bra, and raise you a rapid-fire monster gun). Her corollary in “Alejandro,” the cyborg queen, trains an army of soldiers; the Evil Mother gives birth to the weapons with which to equip this army. While the army is not explicitly defined as evil, the birthing of their weapons is an act that promotes death instead of life. Rather than retaliate, the Eternal Mother wonders, “How can I protect such perfection without evil?” This is the essential nature and the moral challenge she passes on to her children.


The Dark Queen of “Alejandro” is as menacing and lustful as the Eternal Mother is protective and nurturing. She is an insectile cyborg vampire who exists in darkness and who rules a dystopia redolent with militarism.


She lusts after Alejandro’s barb-wired heart, stroking her red lips as the heart passes by in a funeral procession. This lust takes on added meaning as she opens her mouth and flashes gold fangs. She hides her eyes behind steampunk goggles, sardonically opening each lens one at a time to sing “she won’t look at you.” She’s malevolent and uncomfortably seductive, even though she never participates directly in the rampant sexual performances.


She is attended by a sleeping armed soldier and a high-ranking officer who peers over her shoulder as she reviews the troops. Under her watchful gaze, the soldiers perform their martial drills and Spartan training against the backdrop of a screen where images of war and violence are projected. The training exercises militarize sexuality and sexualize militarism. The eroticism is muted by their aggression and violent movements as the soldiers circle, embrace, shove, choke, and slam each other to the ground. These are the Cyborg Queen’s offspring. But she’s not birthing a new type of humanity; she’s overseeing the training of an all-too-familiar master race of soldiers.


The Innocent Starchild vs. The Nun
In a vast nursery of gestating heads in translucent wombs, one Starchild has already begun to mature and take complete form. She is the new race in its infancy. Her wide-eyed look and playful nature speak of virginal innocence and oneness with oneself. She has not yet had to fight the battles for self-acceptance and respect that her older siblings are engaged in. She’s just a baby. She still remembers who and what she is. She is spiritual by her very nature. Like her Eternal Mother, she’s a creature of Light.


In contrast, the nun of “Alejandro” represents the grieving woman who buried Alejandro’s love. She flees to religion for solace, not only from her grief, but also from other unfulfilling relationships that require more than she wants to give (“Don’t want to talk, don‘t want to touch, just smoke my cigarette and hush”). Dressed in passionate red, she ingests rosary as an act of communion, and prays for release from the love/attraction of these men.


When she is dressed in pure white and bearing St Peter’s Crosses (papal symbol of humility), she seems to have achieved the spiritual release and wisdom sought by her red novice. She also appears free of the lust that drives Gaga to bed and dominate the soldier in the barracks. But lust is imposed on her by the soldiers: they surround and force her into a violent group grope in which she eventually sacrifices her religious purity for not-entirely-mutual sexual desire. In a clearly wry moment during the orgy/rape scene, however, the white nun’s cross over her crotch is revealed to be an arrow pointing to her vagina, as if to say…no no, gay boys, it goes in HERE! It’s also a sight gag: See, I have a vagina. No penis.


The Essential Gagas
To perform the central character in both videos, Gaga literally strips herself down to the essentials. In “Alejandro,” director Steven Klein forced her to cut her hair and appear without makeup, to make her feel more vulnerable in keeping with her character. In the barracks scene, she wears only a nude set of Calvin Klein underwear, silk hose, and pumps with a sensibly high heel of perhaps four inches. Her eyebrows are bleached and she wears virtually no makeup except for dark lipstick, giving her a pale, ethereal, fragile look. Even at her most sexually aggressive, she seems almost doll-like, the kind you would take home, put up on your shelf, and dust occasionally.


The Gaga of “Born This Way” is also minimally costumed and makeup. Most shocking is that Gaga gives up shoes and stockings altogether. She dances barefoot, wearing only a half-sole dance shoe for added stability and traction. In stark contrast, this Gaga is fierce and muscular, both physically and emotionally. This is not some porcelain doll, this is a strong woman fighting for her freedom from prejudice and condemnation, and celebrating her liberation.


The Pas de deux
In “Alejandro,” Gaga seeks to gain acceptance within the group of soldiers through sexual domination. The scene is highly sexual, yet not erotic: desperation and frustration characterize the mood.


None of the characters in this scene derive any kind of pleasure or even sexual release. Gaga’s partner responds to her advances with violent aggression bordering on rape. Both force themselves into this sexual pas de deux, and neither is satisfied by it.


In “Born This Way” Gaga partners with model Rick Genest (Rico), aka Zombie Boy, in a playful, joyful pas de deux. Using one of her favorite motifs, the mirrored performance, Gaga’s makeup mimics Rico’s whole-body tattoos, and she wears a matching Mugler tuxedo (which may reference her male alter-ego, Jo Calderone, instead of Madonna as some surmise). Alternately coltish and fiercely passionate, Gaga uses Rico as partner and sometimes prop, while he remains largely impassive as one would expect a non-hungry zombie to do.


The Dance
Gaga’s relationship to the dance company is quite different in the two films. In “Born This Way,” she celebrates and embraces them in relationships that are non-sexual; they share a common origin, quest, and struggle. This company is as diverse with respect to race, gender, class and fashion as is the human family at large, reinforcing “Born This Way” as anthem and ode to inclusivity.


More importantly, Gaga is the featured dancer, and dances solo throughout the video. BTW has been called Gaga’s liberation album, and this is certainly reflected in her movement, and her fiercely joyous personae.


In “Alexandro,” Gaga’s relationship to the company is fraught with desperate attempts to engage them either as sex partners or as comrades. Gaga has described this as trying to have the same kind of relationship with gay men as they have with each other, but they don’t want her. The dance revolves around the company, not around her. Compared to the rich diversity of “Born This Way,” the dancers in “Alejandro” are homogenous with respect to race (and possibly, gender) and fashion. This homogeneity visually reinforces the film’s German subtext and connection to fascism, which cannot wholly be separated from the notion of a master race that is exclusive by its very definition.


Group Hugs, Gropes and Orgies
“Born This Way” features a number of group scenes in which Gaga lies in a tangle of bodies, touching and being touched, stroking and being stroked.


In some scenes, they lie in amniotic fluid/Mugler latex goo, recalling their common origin as the Eternal Mother’s children. These scenes are highly sensual but not explicitly sexual.


The orgy scene in “Alejandro” is violent and blatantly sexual. The soldier/dancers surround the nun in white, grab her, push her, shove her, toss her, hoist her in the air and throw her down to couple with a soldier on the floor.


In its own queer way, this scene is related to a rite of passage by which Gaga earns acceptance as a soldier. In a decidedly Fosse-inspired ensemble dance, she sheds her Liza with a Z vest, and dons a bra with machine guns attached.


In the end, she gains acceptance not by becoming more herself, but by becoming more like them. It’s not liberation; it’s surrender and resignation. In the closing shot, the red nun’s features dissolve, as if her embrace of religion has consumed her from within.


Implications
The trajectory from “Alejandro” to “Born This Way” signals something of a quantum leap for Gaga musically and narratively. There’s a clear progression in how she creatively, politically, and spiritually portrays female power. Does this reflect a shift in Gaga’s interpretation and/or depiction of a more conventionally recognizable feminist philosophy? More likely, it is a deeper reflection of how she has long defined her personal and artistic mission statement:

“Women are strong and fragile. Women are beautiful and ugly. We are soft spoken and loud, all at once. There is something mind-controlling about the way we’re taught to view women, and my work is both visually and musically a rejection of those things. But more importantly, it is a quest.”
Showstudio.com, In Camera with Lady Gaga, May 2010

Rather than adopting a more recognizable feminist stance, her depiction of the female in “Born This Way” signals a broadening of her visual and musical vocabulary as she pursues her own quest for defining and empowering her own femaleness.

There’s also a clear shift in how she has chosen to shape her stance on LGBTQ equality. The militancy of “Alejandro” clearly stems from its ties to the policy of DADT, which was repealed not long before “Born This Way” was filmed. The song itself was written months before this political watershed, and we all surely know there are battles yet to come for equality on all fronts (marriage, adoption rights, etc.). It is unlikely that Gaga will abandon her strong political activism and advocacy on these issues, but she is striking at the heart of how we become victims of legalized bigotry and social bullying in the first place. Our oppression begins with believing that we are as others define us. When we accept that we are inherently less than because of race, gender, sexual orientation, physical appearance, etc., oppression is easy, whether it is institutional or social.

“Born This Way” also lacks the open attack on religious institutions (specifically the Catholic Church) that foster homophobia and misogyny, and that drive the legal codification of these prejudices. Instead, once again, she broadens her visual and lyrical vocabularies of faith and spirituality to make them as inclusive as the narration of the song itself. No doubt, she will continue to personally and artistically confront religious institutions that promote bigotry, but what she has done in “Born This Way” is to enrich the soil of spiritual alternatives in which this generation can grow and thrive without needing the approval of church or state.

Ultimately, with “Born This Way,” Gaga has shifted the frontline of activism. She has taken the battle away from a focus on outside forces and opponents, and instead towards a deep inward embrace of our inherent self-worth that needs no approval or institutional acceptance, thereby strengthening us both personally and in community. Considering the physical, visual, and musical energy of “Born This Way,” it is clear that the artist has experienced some kind of major leap forward on all fronts. A Hallelujah moment.


Author Bio:
Cheryl Helm is an old transgressive hippie, devoutly politically incorrect to all corners. She sold her soul to rock and roll in the 50s, picked up her first good electric guitar from Patti Smith’s husband (Fred “Sonic” Smith, RIP) in the late 60s, and never looked back. “Rock n roll, bitches, do or die,” as Gaga says. She’s written poetry, prose, the L-Word fan fiction, essays, editorials, music criticism, and some things she can’t quite define. She’s written alone and with others, published in obscure ancient feminist literary journals no one ever heard of, as well as alternative presses, newspapers, Creem Magazine in its glory days, blogs, fan forums, leaving digital traces behind like glitter.

Click here to follow Gaga Stigmata on Twitter.
Click here to “like” Gaga Stigmata on Facebook.

Thursday, 4 November 2010

Free Bitch Feminism: The Post-Gender of Lady Gaga

with Kate Durbin, Lesley Kinzel, and Meghan Vicks


Gaga Stigmata has long wanted to respond to a number of articles that approach Lady Gaga from a feminist stance, or that take issue with Gaga’s work and its depictions of gender and sexuality. To this end we invited Lesley Kinzel - fellow Gaga enthusiast, and recently honored as one 40 Feminists under 40 by the Feminist Press of CUNY - to join us for a discussion regarding Gaga’s place in feminism. We took into account a number of recently published articles and talks given by established feminist scholars, including those by Nancy Bauer, Jack Halberstam, and Camille Paglia, and considered articles written on various blogs, in particular one geared toward body acceptance. We look forward to you joining our discussion in the comments.

In the now-infamous Norwegian interview, Lady Gaga said, “I’m not a feminist! I love men! I hail men.” Six months later, she praised Ann Powers of the Los Angelas Times for “being a little bit feminist, like I am.” How can we make sense of Gaga’s conflicting self-evaluations regarding her own feminism? Should we?

Lesley Kinzel: The Norwegian interview was actually the first thing that drew my attention to Gaga as possibly being anything other than the standard pop star, mostly because of what she says immediately prior to disavowing feminism:
If I was a guy and I was sitting here with a cigarette in my hand, grabbing my crotch and talking about how I make music because I love fast cars and fucking girls, you'd call me a rock star. But when I do it in my music and in my videos, because I'm a female, because I make pop music, you're judgmental.
Her response to the journalist’s follow-up question about feminism struck me as a knee-jerk reaction to a word and/or identity she doesn’t seem to have given much thought – going directly to the stereotype that feminists hate men – though her prior point could easily qualify as a feminist perspective. The LA Times article was printed six months later, and this may not so much be a conflicting comment as it is evidence of an ongoing evolution in Gaga’s understanding of feminism. She may not like the word, still, but I’d argue she has progressively moved in a more feminist direction in subsequent interviews, and even in her increasingly aggressive persona.

Meghan Vicks: I agree with you, Lesley, that the contexts in which Gaga made these statements shape their implications. I also felt that in the first interview, her statement “I’m not feminist!” was supposed to be sarcastic since it followed some pretty astute remarks about how men and women are judged differently when it comes to sex. It would be as if I, a graduate student of comparative literature, after launching into an impassioned speech about the virtues of Shakespeare or the hilarity of Nabokov, confessed, “Ugh! Literature, I abhor literature!”

So the context of Gaga’s statement during that interview either points to its sarcasm, or to her aversion to the word “feminist” itself - which is not an uncommon aversion, even among those who readily agree with feminist principles. Of course, now we’re tiptoeing along the edge of controversial territory: what does feminism stand for, and why has it become such a negatively charged word in contemporary society? That discussion likely falls outside the scope of this one, but for our present purposes, it behooves us to acknowledge that in Gaga’s generation, many feminist-acting and feminist-thinking individuals are wary of the term “feminist” itself.

I also think her statement “I’m not feminist! I love men! I hail men!” can be placed in the same category as her assertion, “Pop stars should not eat.” These statements are, I think, purposely radical - they are anti-feminist, blindly adoring and worshiping of men, pro-starvation for the sake of an admirable body that fits today’s standards of beauty and sex appeal, even somewhat misogynistic. They are, in other words, statements that today’s contemporary pop star projects. If Gaga is playing the role of the contemporary pop star, then she will make statements like these; and hopefully, if we’re horrified by what we hear, we’ll become a “little bit feminist,” like she tells Ann Powers she is.


Finally, if you watch the full interview, it becomes apparent that Gaga is rejecting a stereotypical version of feminism: that feminists “hate” men. She assumes that the interviewer perceives feminists as men-hating, and so she pushes against that label.

Kate Durbin: What you said, Meghan, about “feminist-thinking individuals” of Gaga’s generation being “wary of the term ‘feminist’ itself” seems particularly relevant to Gaga’s project. She is the self-proclaimed “free bitch,” and her agenda is one that, as Lesley points out, seems to merge ever more directly towards her generation’s particular political needs, as her own image becomes ever more aggressively political. In fact, she claims her new album Born This Way is an anthem of her generation’s deepest desires, and she increasingly sees herself as a spokesperson for and embodiment of these desires, talking repeatedly about “not letting her fans down” and wanting to “be good for [them].”

Gaga at DADT rally in Maine, giving her speech “The Prime Rib of America”

In context of the desire for free individualism, Gaga’s agenda is one that promotes “being yourself.” It’s not always easy to “be yourself” when you are taking on a historically heavy mantle every day (i.e. that of the token “Feminist”). Gaga, like many of her generation (her fans), felt misunderstood and pigeonholed both in school as a kid, and also by the music industry. It seems that when she reacted to the male journalist’s dismissive remark, it was just that – a reaction to being limited as a caricature in a dismissive way, but also because this guy refused to understand, his goal was to put her down. And so she put him in his place. This of course ties in neatly to Meghan’s work on Gaga as Trickster of Pop Culture, how Gaga reflects/mimics those she comes in contact with. She can demure (Barbara Walters) or fight (Asshole Male Journalist) with the best and the worst of them.

As was pointed out, Gaga later revised her stance on feminism, as she is constantly revising herself as her identity fluctuates in this technological, post-post modern age, just as her fans’ identities are also constantly flickering. Sure, she is a little bit feminist. She is also a little bit of a whole lot of other things too, depending on the day, the performance, and what attributes of her fans she is channeling/embodying in an almost Catholic, martyr-like way.

Putting aside what Lady Gaga says about her own feminism, how does her music and performance deal with or speak to issues of gender and identity politics, if at all?

Meghan Vicks: Gaga wields the phallus (her disco stick in “Love Game,” alter-ego Jo Calderone, strap-on and/or rumored dick, her and Beyonce’s plastic cartoon-like guns in Videophone, gun bra in Alejandro) often with tragic and comic results, or to turn the phallus on its head. She undermines the male gaze, performs a multitude of genders, destabilizes traditional gender categories (or maybe even works to move beyond gender), advocates safe sex, and fights for gay rights. She exemplifies a version of a mother that is proud, powerful, and monstrous. All these have been, at various times and in various ways, feminist projects.

Gaga commands the phallus; those men are drawn to her disco stick.

Most of all, (and this is really where I find her feminism, although it might not look like feminism at all), she controls her identity, gives birth to her own identity. I mean this to imply something much more complicated than just creating identity; the term “birthing identity” comes closer to what I have in mind, as it indicates a kind of oxymoron - both natural and constructed simultaneously.

For Lady Gaga performs an identity that is quite paradoxical. On the one hand, her identity is performance, costume, acting, poses, and lies - all these non-essentialist, non-foundationalist, non-immanent modes of identity. On the other hand, her identity is fated, true, “born that way,” and real - that is, essential, foundational, and immanent identity. How can one be simultaneously “born this way” and a stage act? Both the lie and the truth? Gaga is the lie that was “born this way.” Her own statements in various interviews, as well as her music and performance, speak to this paradox.

So what does this have to do with feminism, or issues of gender and identity politics? For one, it puts performative identity in the space of essential identity, thereby at once giving freedom to identity (you’re free to be who you want to be) and legitimacy to identity (it’s true, cause it’s the way you are). Lady Gaga embodies an autonomous identity that is at once created through her own desires and wants, and always already born that way, preexisting those desires in a sense. Her creation of her identity becomes how she was born. And this, I feel, can be a powerfully feminist stance and tool - a method for creating autonomous identities, a method that releases identities from both cultural and essentialist dictates, and conversely empowers one to determine their own created/natural identities.

Kate Durbin: It’s important to note as well that Gaga has, unlike other pop stars, ceremoniously embraced the role of “role model” for young kids. To me, this is one of her most feminist gestures in that she clearly sees herself, as you pointed out Meghan, as a sort of mother-figure, but also as an activist figure. She sends messages to parents of her fans where she claims “your kids are safe with me.” As an activist, Gaga has openly spoken out against homophobia and misogyny in the music business; in fact she ties the two together in such a way that feels very close to third-wave activism of the last couple of decades, a movement that has been as invested in gay rights as women’s rights. And she has encouraged her fans to become active as well - she is, in her mother-marytrdom, very focused on her fans cultivating relationships with one another and feeling “liberated” (the monster ball has been described over and over by Gaga as being about liberation) in their own power, instead of blindly worshipping her. Case in point: a recent tweet from Gaga: "It is through reciprocal loyalty and dedication that vision becomes Justice; Justice for the nerds, the disenfranchised, + the insecure." Pretty radical for a pop star! 

Gaga also, of course, incorporates highly political gestures into her performances. For example, her first VMA performance read very much like a feminist performance art piece along the lines of the female body artists such as Vanessa Beecroft, Hannah Wilke, or Carolee Schneemann, and her second one - with the four discharged service persons as well as the meat dress - also read very feminist and queer activist. Gaga has even gotten involved in politics directly, speaking at a number of rallies against DADT, and becoming a spokesperson for MAC’s Viva Glam Aids Fund along with Cyndi Lauper.


Thus the tradition of feminist activism, as well as female partnerships, is very strong in her project. Gaga has spoken out against the pitting of female artists against one another, and her collaborations with Beyonce are examples of  how Gaga actively works against the notion of women as cutthroat competitors in the music industry. Gaga has said that she wanted the Telephone video to be more about Beyonce than about her, and when she collaborated on Beyonce’s Videophone video, she said she wanted to honor Beyonce by dressing like her. She called herself Beyonce’s “fly girl.”

Beyonce with Gaga as fly girl  in Videophone

Beyond these more traditional examples of Gaga’s feminist gestures, though, I do think Gaga problematizes traditional feminist criticisms. The way Gaga destabilizes gender identity generally is the real root of her danger. She is a threat to feminism in that her ultimate goal is to render it unnecessary, in favor of a larger global shift toward polymorphous gender and sexual identities. And so anyone who is bound up (and yes, feminism can be very binding) in ideals that truck in identifying proudly as a man or a woman (whether gay or straight, fat or thin, black or white, etc.) and promoting the rights of their “group,” well, they will feel threatened by a project such as Gaga’s, which promotes a new kind of group - a group of monsters - not entrenched in such old-fashioned binaries and identifiers. As, perhaps, they should be threatened.

Lesley Kinzel: Amongst Gaga’s plentiful efforts at unsteadying gender, my favorite moment continues to be the outstanding crotch-shot of Telephone, as I think it beautifully illustrates Gaga’s playful relationship with gender norms and expectations.


I originally described this scene on my blog:
Gaga... jumps up and angrily grabs at the bars, climbing to hang from them with her head out of the frame and her legs spread, while the guards walk away saying to each other, “I told you she didn't have a dick.” “Too bad.” This, of course, is an in-joke, a reference to the much-ballyhooed rumors that Lady Gaga is intersexed, rumors she often seems entirely too amused by to fully discredit. If Gaga had any real anxiety about her penis rumors, she’s had multiple opportunities to address them before now. Instead she seems to have chosen to both dismiss and fan the flames at the same time.
And so it comes to pass that in the first minute... Gaga is literally shoving her blurred-out, fishnet-clad snatch in our faces, in what functions as a comment on our communal sense of entitlement to the most private aspects of the lives of those we elevate to the heights of fame. As a culture, we fancy that even the genitalia of our stars is our business, and we’re most interested in that (as in anything) when we think they’ve got something to hide. But the most sublime aspect of this presentation is the digital blurring. The image is a huge tease that ultimately tells us nothing. There could be a vag there, sure, or there could be the fabled “little bit of a penis,” or she could be smooth and slit-free as a Barbie doll. Gaga’s crotch shot says: is this what you want, a look around a woman’s body that is literally incarcerated, the freedom to explore her like she’s nothing more than a doll? Well, fuck you. Some information is still not public property. Some privates, it seems, are still private. Too bad.
I was surprised, as other analyses of the video poured in, to find that many viewers saw this in  totally different terms - the common take seemed to be that Gaga was attempting to prove wrong those who were accusing her of not being entirely female, and when combined with the casting of female bodybuilders in the roles of prison guards, some viewers read the entire event as overtly transphobic. The problem is, Gaga was never rumored to be transgender, but rather the rumors were that she is intersexed, which muddies the waters a bit. Given that intersexed bodies can often defy culturally-comfortable gender binaries even with a non-blurred look at their business, the suggestion that Gaga is neither male nor female - even if you can perform a close-up examination! - creates a persona that is even more sexually confounding/challenging.

Gaga herself has said:
I love the rumor that I have a penis. I’m fascinated by it. In fact, it makes me love my fans even more that this rumor is in the world because 17,000 of them come to an arena every night and they don’t care if I’m a man, a woman, a hermaphrodite, gay, straight, transgendered, or transsexual. They don’t care! They are there for the music and the freedom. This has been the greatest accomplishment of my life - to get young people to throw away what society has taught them is wrong. Gay culture is at the very essence of who I am and I will fight for women and for the gay community until I die. (Source)
I think all this fits neatly with Kate’s assertion above, that “[Gaga] is a threat to feminism in that her ultimate goal is to render it unnecessary, in favor of a larger global shift toward polymorphous gender and sexual identities.” Gaga reliably drives critical conversation about gender as an identity and as a reality not as easily pinned down as we’d like to believe, building discussion even amongst people who are mostly interested in her as an allegedly-vapid pop star. If there is not yet such a thing as postgender, Gaga may be a harbinger of it.

Does Lady Gaga express strength as a woman, or self-objectification? Are the two mutually exclusive?

Meghan Vicks: Lady Gaga certainly performs self-objectification. Whether or not she expresses strength as a woman is more difficult for me to determine. As I see it, she embodies strength through her self-objectification - but is that strength intimately tied to her femininity or womanhood? I’m not sure. It’s a strength tied to her person and performance - but that person and performance is constantly complicating and blurring categories of gender. I guess, I sometimes wonder whether or not Lady Gaga is performing as a gendered woman at all, or is she rather performing as a being that’s beyond gender - both masculine and feminine at once, and neither masculine nor feminine, and everything in between and beyond.

I mean, how do you categorize (gender-wise) Lady Gaga in her Kermit the Frog dress? (And, for our biology-in-the-know readers, I should point out that some frogs can change sex! - to complicate our matter even further).



What do you make of Gaga’s gender when she shows up looking like this?


Or this:



But let me go back a few steps.

Does Gaga turn herself into an object of the sexual desire of others? Yes. Does she market herself as a commodity to be capitalistically consumed? Yes. Does she perform as a slave owned by others? Yes. She certainly turns herself into an object, but here’s the kicker: she never relinquishes her autonomy. And another kicker: oftentimes, the object she turns herself into subverts the subject’s desires. She’s an (oxymoronic?!) autonomous object!

You know how the paparazzi are always trying to get the million-dollar up-skirt shots of female celebrities? (And I love your discussion, Lesley, of Gaga’s crotch shot in Telephone ... Maybe we should make another discussion in which we just write about the metamorphoses and statements that Gaga’s crotch has made!) Well, check out Gaga:


When I saw this photo, I thought Gaga’s giving them her up-skirt, quite literally! Hasn’t she also turned her nether regions into a big, pink, uni-broweed, hairy monster! Or, another example:


In the above photo shoot for Rolling Stone, Gaga embodies many signifiers of a sex object: feminine curves, blond, doll-like, naked. But her curves are hyperbolic and somewhat disconcerting, and the plastic bubbles make her look misshapen and tumor-ridden, and then there’s the dead or passed-out or climaxed-out or orgasm-riding bodies surrounding her. It’s a scene of a sex orgy, and Gaga’s definitely a sex object (maybe even the phallus: she is the only upright figure), but it’s an orgy and an object that are a bit (or a lot) off-putting. I’ll usher out America’s stereotypical, main-stream, culturally-determined, heterosexual, white, middle-class, average-weight Straw Man: you wanna join this orgy, Mr. Straw Man? Not in a million years, he says as he carefully backs away.

So yeah, Gaga turns herself into an object, but often renders that object monstrous, or even grants that object a subjectivity of its own. And she therefore exhibits strength and power via her self-objectification. But Lady Gaga’s strength and power aren’t necessarily tied up with womanhood. She is a being whose gender is so other-than, so beyond our typical categories of masculine and feminine, that I just can’t say she’s exhibiting strength as a woman. She is an incredibly powerful woman, but her strength is not simply an expression of her being one.

This is quite different from Madonna, who performs strength always as a woman. In the sense that, you can’t divorce Madonna’s performance from her womanhood. I mean, it is thrilling and empowering to watch Madonna, decked out in a man’s suit, dance and aggressively grab her crotch in the video Express Yourself - but a lot of the thrill comes from that fact that she’s a woman who usurps the position of a man. Come on girls!  Do you believe in love? ‘Cause I got something to about it. ... Do you know what it feels like in this world for a girl? ... Express yourself don’t repress yourself. Would it sound better if I were a man? You’re the one with the problem. ... Papa don’t preach. ... I can make it alone, my sisters and me.


Madonna is a woman who has taken up the space traditionally belonging to men, and she’s claiming that space for women as well. On the whole, Madonna’s project has been about the spectacle of being a woman, the expression of feminine power, the reclaiming of sexuality for women. This is not what Lady Gaga does.

Lesley Kinzel: I love the inevitable comparisons of Gaga and Madonna (the yardstick by which all female pop stars are measured), because while it’s true that without Madonna, Lady Gaga would assuredly not exist, it is reductive to argue that Gaga does nothing that Madonna hasn’t done before (for one, I never recall Madonna wearing plush toys, though I may have missed that particular photo shoot).

I agree, Meghan, that what Gaga does differs in some critical ways. Madonna has historically exploited our notions of traditional beauty and femininity by performing an over-the-top model of female sexuality. Madonna does this with a wink and a nod, but ultimately she is reproducing the female body as sexual object. Madonna’s use of drag in the Express Yourself video (from which the still image above is taken) evokes not so much true gender fuckery as it does the absent man whose clothes she’s borrowed. Madonna’s performance can be read as critical, certainly, but it can also just as easily be read as underscoring the status quo. She is often a mannequin on which various characters - ingenue, bitch, hapless maiden - are drawn.

Gaga, on the other hand, is her own object and as such defies the archetypes on which Madonna’s performance relies. Gaga’s ingenue goes to prison in Telephone, and her hapless maiden kills the man who purchases her body at auction in Bad Romance. By melding objectification with action and/or violence, Gaga forcibly controls her circumstances, even after being thrown from a balcony by her faithless lover (Paparazzi). As an object also capable of unpredictable violence, Gaga can depict such gendered expectations without being pinned down by them.

It really surprises me that people get so hung up on Gaga’s sexuality - her violence is far more fascinating to me.

Meghan Vicks: Omg me too! We’ll have to talk about Gaga’s violence at a later date! ;)

Jack Halberstam has said, in Telephone’s “brave new world of Gaga girliness, we are watching something like the future of feminism. [...] What one wants to inspire is new work that one barely recognizes as feminism, and that’s what I’m going to call Gaga feminism. [...] Instead of becoming women, we should be unbecoming women - that category itself seems vexed and problematic.” Reactions and/or thoughts?

Meghan Vicks: As I talked about above, when I watch Gaga, I feel as though I’m watching a performance that so complicates and renders ambiguous traditional categories of gender that I can’t say Lady Gaga is performing as a woman. In this respect, I think Gaga heralds a kind of future of feminism, as Halberstam suggests.

But then I think: hasn’t this been done before? Haven’t many performers complicated categories of gender? For instance, how is what drag queens do different from what Gaga does? Drag queens certainly problematize fixed conceptions of gender, and display how all genders are create via performance. And besides drag queens, there are countless gender and sex performance artists whose work deeply complicates perceptions of gender.

However, I think Lady Gaga performs gender in a way that not only complicates its categories, but makes them completely irrelevant. Almost as if she does not want to be gendered at all. This is her performance: a being that refuses to be distinguished by gender. Her performance presents a gendered body that not only exhibits the split between biological sex and culturally-constructed gender, but moreover thwarts attempts to be controlled or defined by gender. She’ll perform an angelic feminine one minute, a trampy vixen the next, and a day later she appears on a magazine cover as Jo Calderone - but never do these genders determine who Lady Gaga is (and this is probably why she performs so many different gendered beings, but also beings that can’t necessarily be gendered - robotic, monstrous, abject, cyborgian, alien). I think she’s after a kind of identity that isn’t categorized according to gender: a post-gender body.

So this is what I think Halberstam is getting at when she talks about Gaga ushering in a new kind of feminism that “unbecomes women,” that goes beyond the category of woman.

I guess we should also ask why more socially-active feminists would want to go beyond the category of woman, and how a feminism “that barely looks like feminism” would be a useful (if at all) political and social tool for progressive change in the political and social spheres. Because Gaga certainly envisions at least one of her roles to be a vehicle for political and social change. Her HIV/AIDS activism, as well as her work to repeal DADT, both figure her as a social activist who uses her persona to promote her cause.

Kate Durbin: Agreed! Gaga pushes beyond the categories of woman or man or even human to that of the post-human. As Donna Haraway says, “the posthuman is not a singular, defined individual, but rather one who can ‘become’ or embody different identities and understand the world from multiple, heterogeneous perspectives.” This relates not only to what Gaga does with gender in her videos and performances or on the street, but it even ties back to her mystical union with her fans - how she sees herself as a flickering screen of their desires and needs. To totally freak Walt Whitman, “Gaga is large, she contains multitudes.”

In other words, Gaga does not just speak for her fans, she is them.

A sculpture by shock artists Jake and Dinos Chapman

Which is why I feel that Gaga is writing her own speculative fiction in a sense, with her project, something along the lines of an Ursula LeGuin novel. Le Guin’s characters have mutated beyond one fixed gender but the concerns of her texts are inherently feminist, in that they are imminently concerned with the future of living beings and this planet we call our home. This, to me, seems to be the future of feminism - something larger than just gender rights. It might be interesting to see if Gaga incorporates more of an environmentally-focused feminism into her art/activism of the future. Her new album Born This Way already speaks to issues of biological determinism in its very title.

Gaga is the sci-fi lie that will become the truth. Perhaps she will become the next L. Ron Hubbard, and can save Katie Holmes from Tom Cruise?

Lesley Kinzel: I agree with all of the above, and want to add that “becoming women” is often both limiting (to the individuals who participate in the effort) and limited (to certain people who have bodies incapable of following through on the task). Bodies not biologically sexed as female, bodies that are disabled, bodies that are fat or ugly or simply ill-shaped to represent cultural femininity, all of these are bodies (and people) stuck climbing up the down escalator to womany success. Gaga has played with all these limiting factors - and outer limits - at one time or another, creating, as you have both noted above, a gender that is fluid and changeable and dependent on the outfit, circumstances, or possibly the time of day.

Gaga’s performance as a whole, for me, argues in favor of undoing the very notion of female “power” by undoing not the systems and institutions that dispense that power, as feminism has traditionally sought to do, but by undoing gender itself as a static category. In this respect, I think “unbecoming women” is a good definition of what Gaga does, and a pretty solid feminist approach.

Meghan Vicks: Beautifully put, Lesley.

I also wonder what a beyond-gender society would look like. Because one of the problems with gender is that it is often the first thing we notice about a person: whether that person is a man or a woman, and then how well they fit the corresponding role; that is, to what extent do they “become man” or “become woman.” And the problem with “becoming man” or “becoming woman,” as Lesley so gracefully points out, is that many fail to adequately fill the role – too fat or muscle-ly or tall or masculine to be a woman, too fat or waifish or short or feminine to be a man.

But (cuing John Lennon) imagine if we looked at a person, and we didn’t immediately identify them according to a gender category that carries with it overwhelming cultural baggage, expectations, and assumptions. I think this is the type of identity that Lady Gaga repeatedly performs – one that continuously sidesteps and subverts any and all gender classification. The hope is, I think, that we eventually give up trying to classify Gaga’s gender: not only is it a fool’s errand, but it really does not, and should not, matter.

Writes Nancy Bauer, “Since Gaga herself literally embodies the norms that she claims to be putting pressure on (she’s pretty, she’s thin, she’s well-proportioned), the message, even when it comes through, is not exactly stable. It’s easy to construe Gaga as suggesting that frank self-objectification is a form of real power.” - NY Times Opinionator. Reactions and/or thoughts?

Kate Durbin: Is Gaga “pretty”? I mean compared to Katy Perry, or Rihanna, or Britney, is she pretty? It’s funny because I hear the opposite, often, from younger people - they think Gaga has a big nose or that she looks weird, especially because of how she dresses.

This statement goes back to this idea of “natural” beauty, which Gaga most certainly does not embody except to make meta and therefore implode the image. She also counters this image with her costumes every day. The “natural” beauty of pop stars is an illusion, a culturally constructed and upheld lie that we buy into culturally. Gaga counters this lie all the time with her own lie - a vision of the future that is much more sci-fi and polysexual and post-human. She talks about how she wants to change our view of what is sexy, and how she and her Haus choose costumes that they think are “beautiful” and not simply “kooky.” Gaga has described her performance at the Brit Awards by saying: “I wanted to do a very, very forward performance, something I felt that was a true representation of the future.”  It’s important to note their continued insistence on beauty, which is a much broader and less historically gendered term than prettiness. Umberto Eco’s book History of Beauty comes to mind. That text draws attention to the fact that what is beautiful is is totally malleable throughout time, and often contains that which was previously considered as ugly...or, at times, even contains within in that which we currently view as ugly. It seems Gaga and her Haus are constantly pushing these boundaries and borders, with their future-driven vision.

Gaga as a beautiful futuristic lizard in the Bath Haus of Gaga (Bad Romance video)

I wonder what Gaga would need to look like to convince Ms. Bauer that she was not self-objectifying? Or that her self-objectification was part of her project? She was ridiculed in high school and called “fat.” Would she need to gain a significant amount of flesh now? Because she already warps her “prettiness” and “thinness” and especially her supposed “well-proportions” by obscuring her face and wearing costumes like these:

This is a more subtle, day wear version of Gaga, but check out those hips! Definitely not “thin!”


Here is a stage version. Last time I checked it wasn’t sexy to be covered in [body] hair. Can you imagine Spears doing this? Or even Rihanna? [And, I should add, Gaga’s legs do not look stick-thin here - she looks healthy and ready to rock it].

I love this image of Gaga evoking Leigh Bowery’s pregnant belly costumes - not only is Gaga subverting the notion that a flat belly is desirable, but pregnancy itself is something that can be costumed and paraded at will, by those of either gender. Mother Monster, anyone?

Again, I’m not sure what Gaga could do to assuage Bauer besides actively trying to gain weight, to try and turn herself into a Beth Ditto figure. Beth Ditto is gorgeous and preaches that it’s good to parade your own flesh, no matter what your size. And that is how both these women preach similar messages: “it’s more than okay to be who you are.”  But, for Gaga, fashion is flesh. Who you are is malleable from day to day. Through wigs, through fashion that obfuscates and warps the body. The possibilities are beautiful.

Beth Ditto of The Gossip

Meghan Vicks: I think Bauer’s qualms concerning Lady Gaga’s self-objectification are legitimate: she’s worried that Gaga (and, by proxy, women) too heavily derive power from being objects - that when one utilizes self-objectification to control and claim power, one still only gains power as an object and not as a subject. As such, one’s still not free. To put it another way, can Lady Gaga (and women) be powerful subjects, or are they only powerful as objects?

It’s a good hesitation, and Bauer is right to make it. However, I don’t think that Lady Gaga’s self-objectification so neatly reduces to becoming a desired object in order to wield power over the desiring subject. For one thing, the object Lady Gaga becomes is often undesirable - is an undesirable object that wields power over its subject still an object? I’m tempted to launch into a mess of jargony gobbledy goop, but I’ll hold back for now. Instead, I’ll just say this: does Lady Gaga’s performance exhibit a strict subject/object binary at all? Because wouldn’t it need to if it does, as Bauer suggests, turn Lady Gaga into a powerful object by virtue of her control of our (the subjects’) desires? I don’t think that there are clear distinctions between subject and object in Gaga’s performance; it’s more abject, if anything.

Also, Kate - the points you make about Gaga’s prettiness are spot on. I would add: why can’t Gaga be traditionally beautiful and still attack and make problematic conceptions of beauty? Is this only a project for the ugly?

Lesley Kinzel: I would also take issue with “well-proportioned.” Gaga is slender, certainly, and has received a some disdain for her comment that “pop stars shouldn’t eat” - but she is also small-busted in an industry in which implants are the norm. As a result, her barely-clad body, without oversized breasts and with soft flesh apparent, looking unlike the strictly-toned and top-heavy standard shape to which we are all accustomed and which we rarely truly see anymore, seems extra-vulnerable in its failure to be perfect, and in Gaga’s apparent willingness to display it without shame. That said, I agree we rarely get to see Gaga’s actual shape, as she so often obscures it with exaggerated fashion or with computer manipulation, as in the video Bad Romance.

The Beth Ditto comparison is apt, but for a very different reason. Whereas Gaga reshapes and obscures her (mostly) acceptable body shape into something monstrous and grotesque, Ditto strives to show hers off exactly as it really is - monstrous in its natural state so far as beauty standards go - without adherence to fashion “rules” set in place to enable those who see her to be more comfortable with her fatness. Beth’s fat is front and center where Gaga’s slenderness is fuzzy-edged; both women are advocating a revolution of the feminine body from opposite directions.

The argument: Women are still rewarded for pleasing men; Gaga’s power comes from turning herself into what men want.

Kate Durbin: This read seems way too simple for our Gaga. If someone were to state this to me, I would counter with a few questions. Do men, or to be more specifically, do masculinists want bubble dresses? Do they want crime scene taped bodies? Are they turned on by razor blade or cigarette sunglasses? Do they want to be scorched by fire bras or shot down with gun bras?


When Gaga first wore her fire bra at the Much Music Awards, she explained her costume by saying that her breasts were seen as a weapon, therefore she was going to literally turn them into that. Gaga turns herself into what men want, or more specifically what masculinists believe her to be. That’s what the gun bra, fire bra, and meat dress were all about. Masculinists see but a piece of meat, so Gaga gives them exactly what they “see” - a piece of meat. In order, of course, that the Male Gaze might “see” itself.

Did anyone else notice that Gaga’s tasty ass hung out of her meat dress? Not a fashion roadkill moment, methinks, but rather a direct reference to the ravenous attention over panty-flashing Britney and Lindsey, etc. Not to mention a gleeful, teenage, mooning-the-authorities moment!

So yes, Gaga’s turning herself into what men want does give her power - but not power over men in the way a woman in a scantily clad dress might get a guy to buy her a drink at a bar. Gaga’s fire bra wields real power in that with it she actually blows up the Male Gaze!


Gaga is no Monica Lewinsky, that’s for sure!

Laura Mulvey explains the Male Gaze thus: “The determining male gaze projects its phantasy on to the female form which is styled accordingly. In their traditional exhibitionist role women are simultaneously looked at and displayed, with their appearance coded for strong visual and erotic impact so that they can be said to connote to-be-looked-at-ness. Woman displayed as sexual object is the leit-motif of erotic spectacle: from pin-ups to striptease, from Zeigfeld to Busby Berkeley, she holds the look, plays to and signifies male desire.”

Gaga is doing more than just exploding the Male Gaze, though. Gaga also toys with Homosexual Gaze in interesting ways. Meghan and Eddie McCaffray talked in their great breakdown of the Alejandro video about how, although Gaga is writhing around with men on a bed in this video, it’s all a pose. The men are all clearly gay. There will be no [traditional] consummation of the sex act, and so we are left with our own frustrated libidos, our screen surrogates therefore failing in their fetishistic representations of any “straight” forward sexualities. And so we are forced to look at ourselves, really look, at what it is we expect our surrogates to do for us, what we expect them to confirm about ourselves.

Gaga and her gay partner in the Alejandro video

I am also thinking of course of the Telephone video, of the women’s prison yard, of Gaga kissing that hot, body-building butch Heather Cassils, about how Gaga’s goal was to celebrate her lesbian friends (and, I would assume, celebrate her own bi-sexuality). And yet there is here a certain stereotypical lesbian fantasy, perhaps even a level of objectification of Cassils, who plays no major role in the video. But because lesbian fantasies in particular have so little air time in contemporary pop culture, this could be seen as a radical and important first start - flaunting what is usually seen as non-sexy by the wider, homophobic, and even more lesbian-phobic audience. And yet we also have to realize that something men want - to go back to the original question about Gaga turning herself into what men want - is for two hot women to make out. This seems, at first glance, to be a classic, straight while male fantasy. But only if those are straight, white, femme women making out. Because straight white masculinists feel super threatened by hot butch women making out with “their” femme partners. So in that way Gaga is yet again sticking it - and I do mean sticking it - to the Male Gaze.

Gaga making out with Cassils in the Telephone video - straight and gay women across the world got wet watching this!

Lastly, I want to add that Gaga subverts the Male Gaze and the Homosexual Gaze by becoming male, in her performance as Jo Calderone. This photo below is fascinating because it plays into the gender stereotype of masculinity - the heading “Homeboys Don’t Smile” is telling. Gaga is playing with butch culture here, and also showing us that gender along with its various expectational baggage is something we can don and subvert at the same time. But the awareness of the Gaze - that we are being watched, and judged- is always present in some capacity in all that Gaga does.



Meghan Vicks: I would also add that Gaga does not buy into the stereotype that men are rendered powerless by a desirable object, which is really, in my mind, an insulting idea about men that still carries too much credence. What you say, Kate, about Gaga subverting the Male Gaze by forcing it to “see itself,” leads me to think that such a project not only problematizes the desires of the Male Gaze, but moreover works to free men from the overwrought stereotypes that the Male Gaze implies about them - that they are driven completely by their libidos, as if their dicks point and their minds hypnotically and without-thought follow, or that we can simply put before them a decked-out pin-up girl and they’ll melt into mush. Doesn’t the Male Gaze ironically indicate that men are bent-over slaves, mere peons of the yearnings of their little-godlike phalluses and idolized balls?

Kate Durbin: This is a great point, Meghan. After all, Gaga’s sheer popularity points to the fact that culturally we’ve already moved past such a narrow view of male sexual desire in practical terms (if male sexuality ever really looked like that anyway, practically, which I doubt). Though we haven’t moved past it in terms of our dangerously entrenched cultural belief system. This is also why I specified masculinists as opposed to men, because men are as varied as women in their sexual proclivities. Also, many women can unfortunately be masculinists, buying into certain cultural beliefs about how they should look in order to please men, becoming gruesome caricatures in their pursuit of the perfect rendering of the masculinist vision. I think Heidi Montag from the MTV reality show The Hills, with her excessive plastic surgeries, is a sad example of this.

The argument: Lady Gaga’s fashion choices are a dangerous model for young girls and feminism. “I am not laying the blame at your weirdly attired feet Gaga, but, your get up got me thinking about how can we expect young girls to value themselves and their qualities when their daily exposure and consumption is about seeing sex sell, be cool and the way to get ahead? It is frightening just how many steps back are being taken in women being treated as equals. And it’s not men pushing us back but other women who feel the need to use sex to get ahead!” - Snezna, We Are The Real Deal

Lesley Kinzel: I find Gaga’s sartorial choices less problematic for young girls than those of your Christina Aguileras and your Britney Spearses, mostly because Gaga is far less overtly marketed to that group. I’d argue these Gaga-contemporaries are a greater danger - and influence - by candidly selling to that demographic while simultaneously portraying adult concepts of sexiness, thereby representing almost a how-to for young girls in precocious sexuality. Both Britney and Christina began in the entertainment industry as child stars, and this is part of their appeal for both kids and adults; we’ve been able to watch them lose their innocence, which holds voyeuristic pleasure for adults, and a model to follow for young girls.

We’ve never seen Gaga as innocent or childlike; her persona sprung fully adult and fully formed from the ether. This is not to suggest that Gaga doesn’t appeal to young girls, or that she doesn’t deal in sex, but that her approach is more advanced. Gaga is strange and complex and even subversive where Britney and Christina were blank slates on which an audience could project its expectations and desires. Gaga’s fashion is expressive and unexpected at the very least, and it’s difficult to make a case that she is underscoring the bland concept that “sex sells” so much as she is interrogating it.

I may be alone in this, but I am inclined to think that if Gaga is teaching anything, teaching young girls to be subversive is not a bad idea.

Kate Durbin: I would seriously love to see little girls wearing fire bras and razor blade sunglasses to school. How awesome would that be? It makes me want to have a little girl so she can dress like that. And a little boy too, for that matter. Little little monsters. No one would eff with them.

Meghan Vicks: You know what pisses me off? Judgments about women’s bodies, and policing of women’s clothing, all in the name of feminism. I really fucking hate statements like the one above, which was published, by the way, on a supposedly body-acceptance website.

I get it. America is afraid of sex (but not violence!). Feminists have fought for years to emancipate women from a pernicious and culturally-entrenched sexual objectification, that renders women the mere playthings and objects owned and controlled by male desire. But it makes me really nervous when feminists, in the name of feminism, try to own and control women’s bodies just like the patriarchal culture they are trying to undermine.

I realize, for instance, that women who wear the burqa or the veil are wearing garments that signify a lifestyle that is controlled by men, but is it any better for Western feminists to claim they “know better” than those who wear the burqa? There’s a battle taking place, and it’s always taking place on women’s bodies. And I realize that when Lady Gaga shows up for a baseball game in her underwear, when she dresses to project a sexual being, or when she wants to ride your disco stick on a subway train, she embodies a sexual object. But when you “know better” than Lady Gaga, when you want her to cover up, (or those wearing the burqa to uncover), you’re controlling her body (and theirs) - you’re objectifying women.

Stop making women’s bodies the battlegrounds for these issues. Stop politicizing women’s bodies.

And another thing: don’t we have the right to be sexual beings, and to enjoy being sexual beings? Even if Gaga did not turn herself into a monstrous desired object, if, for instance, she performed a one-dimensional sexuality a la Britney Spears or Katy Perry, I would still defend her right to parade around in her panties, to glorify in her sexuality, and not be blacklisted as a whore, not be labeled a detriment to our straw-children, and not be reduced her sexuality.

Ok, I’m putting my soapbox away.

Kate Durbin: Preach it, Meghan! I could not agree more. This makes me think of the recent Gaga-esque performance of two French women in protest of the recent burqa ban by wearing burqas and hot pants on the streets of Paris. It’s all about being a free bitch, baby.

I want to address the critique of Gaga’s “weirdly attired feet,” because I for one am obsessed with her shoes. It seems relevant to bring up performance artist Vanessa Beecroft again, a female body artist who enlists models to stand in galleries, gawked at by spectators, nearly nude in impossibly high heels for hours until their feet bleed. Sometimes they pass out.

Models suffering through a Vanessa Beecroft performance / Naomi Campbell eating it on the runway

Like Beecroft’s girls who are performing cultural expectations for models and allowing the viewer to see the intense physical suffering (usually hidden behind the scenes) that their roles require, Gaga is - as a performer of fame, as meta-pop star - allowing the world to watch her “suffer” for her pop stardom daily, as she costumes her feet in impossibly heavy and monstrous footwear.

Gaga eating it in the airport

Gaga is literalizing what is considered sexy for women - high, high heels - to a grotesque degree. Think models falling down on runways, think Barbie’s shoes, how Barbie’s feet are perpetually curved, how Barbie would fall over if she really had those proportions. Think Chinese foot binding. And Gaga alters her feet at risk to her own well-being, even falling down at times. Once again, it’s important to note that Gaga is always Gaga - her life is her lie is her art, she falls for it every day.


What Gaga is doing with her footwear is more than just critiquing painful beauty expectations for women generally and pop stars specifically. Gaga sees suffering for one’s art as a positive thing, suffering as a way of transmutation. The pain Gaga’s feet experience is a price to be paid in order, like the performance artist Orlan who has undergone numerous plastic surgeries in service of becoming post-human, to evolve.

Orlan during one of her surgeries

The shoes make Gaga robot, cyborg, monster, lizard, alien, at various turns. Her paws (which neatly complement her monster “claws” ) were created by Alexander McQueen, known for his future-driven couture visions that merge the animal and “natural” in gorgeous, grotesque ways. The shoes appear practically fused to her body, a part of instead of apart from her. They are the lie she’s told over and over in order that it might become the shoes. And as for the pain the shoes inject, as Gaga said of her bleeding costume at the first VMAs: “When I bleed my clothes bleed too.”

Gaga claimed the original Monster Ball’s concept was about the evolution of civilization and biological evolution, and her albums The Fame and The Fame Monster dealt with the monstrous evolution of the pop star. Her performances have evoked death and rebirth countless times, from her first VMA performance to her performance with Elton John at the Grammys, in which she wore a lizard-like garb and was ejected from a factory chute in order to become a monster, to her Paparazzi video where she falls to her death and resurrects as a disabled, murderous super star.


Gaga’s art and activism (which are the same thing) are all about political, (pop)cultural, and sexual mutations and monstrous re-births. Are these sorts of social (r)evolutions not inextricably linked to biological evolution? As Meghan pointed out earlier, Gaga’s project is important because Gaga is about taking siege of her own identity, giving monstrous birth to herself over and over, like the recent visual piece, "A Special Variety of Soft Skinned Dangerous Game," by artist Jemima Wyman for Gaga Stigmata. Part of that birth is moving with technology instead of against it, part of that is actually morphing her features, the physical possibilities of the body. And birth, as well as beauty, historically have always been tied to pain - not just pain for the sake of prettiness a la getting a breast enhancement to please the Male Gaze and live up to painfully limiting cultural expectations, but pain for the sake of beautiful evolution; the evolution of beauty.


Camille Paglia vs. Lady Gaga
The criticism: Lady Gaga is scripted; she’s not spontaneous. “Lady Gaga is a manufactured personality, and a recent one at that. [...] The Gaga of world fame, with her heavy wigs and giant sunglasses (rudely worn during interviews) looks either simperingly doll-like or ghoulish, without a trace of spontaneity.” - Camille Paglia, The UK Sunday Times Magazine

Lesley Kinzel: You know, to me, Paglia’s entire article reads like a lengthy screed for those kids to get off her lawn. It’s perplexing! This part in particular was baffling: Gaga is hardly the first person to use a manufactured personality or heavy wigs or giant sunglasses to distinguish herself, nor is she the first to keep her sunglasses on during interviews. Would her lack of spontaneity be acceptable to Paglia if she had been doing it longer? Are stage personas always a problem in Paglia’s world? This excerpt reads as though Paglia is chiding Gaga for failing to be authentic, oblivious to the glaring fact that playing with (in)authenticity is a large part of the point.

Kate Durbin: I completely agree with Lesley’s statement that “(in)authenticity is a large part of the point” of Gaga’s project. This reminds me of a parallel critique of Gaga that I encountered in my interview with CBC’s Q, when Gaga was considered by the host of the program to be unoriginal as a musician, manufactured. But Gaga’s project as a meta-pop star requires that she appear to be manufactured to some degree, because she is commenting upon the world we currently live in. She couldn’t be a meta-pop star without “cliched” (perhaps ubiquitous would be a better word) pop star music, and that music had to be comprised of number one hits like Spears’ hits a la literally “Oops I Did It Again.” If she was trying to be “original” - which is impossible anyway - she would have actually been a less interesting artist, frankly. The pursuit of originality is impossible, a modernist notion that buys into the lie of “progress.” And it’s boring to boot.


I see the wigs and sunglasses as part of this as well - Gaga is referencing all these pop stars and fame monsters from Michael Jackson to Princess Diana as a part of her fame project of (in)authenticity, and she is also mirroring and mimicking those she comes in contact with such as Larry King and the Queen, drawing attention to the fact that nowadays all of life is a role, that the street is the stage. Gaga talks about the lie of her work - lying until the lie becomes the truth. What Gaga understands about our zeitgeist is that it’s all a lie. Modernism and progress were a lie and now identity itself is a lie but because these ideas are all lies, we can in effect name them and claim them, putting on the lies that best suit us in order to costume our own truth.

I also agree with Lesley that Paglia’s critique really sounds like the bitter grumblings of the old guard. I think we can safely assume she just doesn’t get it, or us - us being the little monsters, who are authentic in our passions, but want more options available to us than suffering for the illusion of one fixed identity, that of something pure and spontaneous and anti-technological and “organic.”

Lesley Kinzel: Speaking of being “authentic in our passions,” I want to mention Gaga’s YouTube video demonstrating her (ultimately failed) attempt to reach her senator to lobby for the repeal of DADT. Gaga displays an unexpectedly intense earnestness as she reads a speech (seemingly from a laptop off-camera) and then spends the last three minutes listening to her Blackberry fruitlessly ringing Chuck Schumer’s office. When the line goes dead, unanswered, after having sat staring blankly for countless rings, Gaga smiles at the defeat.



And then she tries again.

It would have been easy, understandable even, if this video never saw the light of day, considering that even when Gaga finally reaches Schumer’s voicemail, a recording instructs her that the mailbox is full. Instead, it’s posted and we get to share this odd little experience, mundane in its familiarity and yet weighted with anticipation that we will be privy to a private conversation between Lady Gaga and her senator. It’s bizarre in its existentialism. Don’t we love it when stars are just like us.

I’m a fan, if that weren’t obvious, but even I was a little astonished by this video. In it, Gaga is eager, unsure, even awkward, and these are not sides of her we usually see. Watching Gaga make this call and put herself out there as caring deeply about this particular issue makes it accessible and real. While Gaga may be a meticulously constructed personality, that does not make her not real. The takeaway is that an obsession with the superficial does not erase an ability to care deeply about issues - to be passionate.

Paglia argues that Gaga is dispassionate, unspontaneous, and insincere; I argue that Paglia has not seen enough of Gaga to make this case. This is a woman capable of both wearing a dress too heavy to walk in, and also of emphatically pleading with the United States government to commit to social justice on DADT in a video with production values so low it was obviously something thrown together at the spur of the moment. Neither, to me, rings hollow, and the one does not cancel out the other.

Kate Durbin: Gaga’s video didn’t read hollow to me, either, Lesley. Like you, I was moved. But it did read as performative, as performative as anything I’ve seen her do. I would be surprised if she didn’t do a run-through beforehand, and didn’t know ahead of time that the senator wouldn’t answer. Gaga’s patriotic outfit with her ever-present drag makeup seemed intentional, and just goes to show how politics are a drag show. The flag in the background, even the utilizing of her full “real” name, therefore rendering all politicians’ names stage names, yes, even the awkward pauses, felt as much a performance as her TV performances, which she relentlessly scripts and practices beforehand. We associate these things with authenticity because they are American and familiar, but one of the things Gaga does so beautifully is call attention to how the characteristics of America itself are bizarre and campy. Her Telephone video is another great example of this.

Her video to the senator is also interesting because, theoretically, we should all be able to get through to our senators. If Gaga can’t, we sure can’t. Her performance is pointing to a major problem - there is, in effect, no man behind the curtain. Just as with Gaga there is no Stefani Germanotta behind the curtain. But there is the power of the performance, something Obama himself utilized in his campaign to great success.

Like you, Lesley, I think Gaga projects something that is so passionate, and more (beyond?) authentic than those who claim to be authentic, and that is what I connected to in this video as well as in her red carpet performance at this year’s VMAs, when she walked the white carpet with the four discharged gay service persons. I actually wept when I witnessed that. Perhaps by revealing the performativity of life itself, how ideals and values can be performed every minute, Gaga reveals how these things can be tools that can serve all of us in order that we can perform what really matters - compassion. And, consequently, she reveals how the old methods - whether technological (i.e. the perpetually busy telephone line vs. the viral power of youtube), political (DADT’s hypocrisy vs. “If You Don’t Like It Go Home,” Gaga’s motto from her speech “The Prime Rib of America”), or otherwise (man/woman binaries vs. Gaga-esque polymorphous sexuality) - are failing us, with their false claims to spontaneity and authenticity and even goodness. They are just as much as charade as anything else, but their evil is that they pretend they are not charades. They parade themselves as the Truth. But they ring hollow, Liberty bell, because they are.

Lesley Kinzel: The makeup and the flag in the background truly made this video for me. It’s true - Gaga doesn’t really do irony so much as she does flamboyant reproduction, much in the way that drag is an amplified performance of gender. Both require affection for their origins. I loved it. I think her performance is often confusing to many because culturally we have a predetermined idea of what “authenticity” looks like - it’s a serious face, a dark suit and a red tie. When Gaga dares to bring a Big Issue to the VMA red carpet, a space that is nearly-always lighthearted, that performance is disarming, especially when she does not “use” her dates as clever props (I’m thinking of Gwen Stefani and her abhorrent exploitation of her “Harajuku Girls” years ago) but strictly sticks to her purpose of drawing attention to the injustice of DADT.

I most love that Gaga does not seem to be at all invested in the normal signifiers of someone who wishes to be “taken seriously”. She will advocate for GLBTQ rights with a live chicken strapped to her nethers, if she gets the chance. As an activist myself, there’s a lot of grand inspiration there.

The criticism: Gaga is not sexy. “Furthermore, despite showing acres of pallid flesh in the fetish-bondage garb of urban prostitution, Gaga isn’t sexy at all – she’s like a gangly marionette or plasticised android.” - ibid

Kate Durbin: I think that the criticism that Gaga is not sexy is actually more of a reaction to Gaga being inappropriately over-sexual, as opposed to, say, being “a-sexual” or “non-sexual” (whatever that means). Paglia critiqued her for wearing lingerie to the gym. Only a “sex addict” would wear such a thing to the gym, presumably.

What I love about Gaga and sex is that she displaces it - takes it out of familiar spheres, and parades what is normally hidden out in broad daylight. A recent tweet by Gaga would likely piss off Paglia even more. She said: “I’d wear any of my private attire for the world to see, but I’d rather have an open flesh wound than be caught with a bandaid.” This is part of her art. Her over-the-top sexual attire matches this attitude. She is different than, say, Madonna in this way. While Madonna may have pushed the boundaries of sex in her music videos and on stage, Gaga parades it on the street, at the gym. Places where her fans go, where we all go. It’s this context that rubs Paglia the wrong way, and it’s precisely this context that makes what Gaga’s doing important and dangerous to some. In part, because it is something you or I could do, if we had the guts and proclivity. To wear one’s sexuality - wounded as nature itself is wounded - out in broad daylight as a pair of hot pants is a really beautiful freedom, one that does not yet exist in our culture.

Gaga on her way to the gym

The idea of the grotesque seems relevant here as well - grotesque not as ugly, but so beautiful as to be almost too much to bear. Like the most incredibly intense orgasm! Gaga’s sexuality is so grotesquely sexual as to be “too much,” even death-driven. Think vagina dentata (and now I am thinking of Gaga’s fear that someone will take her creativity from her through her vagina, how that statement flips the whole vagina dentata notion on its head, yes, pun on head).

Gaga is not sexy in a containable feminine sense, like, say, Britney Spears or Katy Perry. She is excessively poly-sexual. See Gaga with the dildo in her pants on the cover of Q, see Gaga looking sexy as hell as Joe Calderone on the cover of Vogue Nippon, see Gaga covered in a dress of [pubic-looking] hair at a nightclub in NYC recently.  Her sexuality goes beyond human sexuality to the realm of raw animal sex, which of course makes me think of Angela Carter’s feminist fairy tales, her wolf-women with voracious sexual appetites. Her sexuality goes beyond animal sex even to protean sexuality, cells merging with other cells. There are undertones of S&M and torture porn in many of her magazine shoots - “deviant” sexualities that speak to the inherent violence of sex, a violence that is a part of nature itself. There is, yes, the android sexuality, the sex doll quality of Gaga - but more in the sense of blurring the lines between the natural and the unnatural, in that nothing is natural or everything is natural, the dildo has simply become the doll. She complicates our notions of the sexuality of those with disabilities - our notion, even, of whether or not a disability is in fact a disability or rather a possibility - with her wheelchair performances and in her Paparazzi video when she dances with crutches and a helmet. Gaga’s sexuality is liquid, ever-present, never revoked to the bedroom, always evoking the ubiquitous sexuality of sheer physical existence on this planet! And frankly, I think it’s hot.

Gaga posing with a dildo and chains for Q Magazine  /  Talk about green porn! The sexuality of crystalline growth

Meghan Vicks: I love the idea that Gaga injects sex into traditionally-sexless spaces. It’s a way of making strange and defamiliarizing both sex and those public places where sex is not supposed to belong. Nevertheless, the public space is ridden with sexual images in that advertising often capitalizes on sex appeal. But those sexual images in advertisements are so ubiquitous and familiar that we don’t notice them all that much - they’re part of the background, or the white noise of urban existence. So when Gaga suddenly steps out without pants to buy coffee, the sexual figure becomes immediately present and recognizable: it’s brought from the background into the foreground, comes into focus from its ubiquitous oblivion.


Regarding Paglia’s specific complaint - that Gaga just isn’t sexy - I have to assume that Paglia has some secret sexiness decoder ring that I haven’t yet learned about. We know standards of beauty are variable and fleeting and fluxing, that what “counts” as beautiful isn’t the same over time, or culturally universal; the same applies to what’s sexy.

So Gaga doesn’t get Paglia off - and the point is?

What seems to bother Paglia the most is that Gaga’s sexuality is sterile and non-reproductive - it’s plastic, android, puppet-like. While I agree that Gaga does, at times, perform a robotic and celluloid sexuality, I can’t understand why Paglia’s only reaction would be a disgruntled “UGH! Not sexy!” echoing throughout the Internet’s ether. Because I wanna ask: what’s potentially problematic about a plasticized sexuality? Isn’t the idea of a plasticized sexuality a reflection of growing contemporary norms regarding the sexual body? Isn’t “plastic surgery” synonymous with “sexual body”? Don’t we hear silicone and think about breasts? And on the other hand, I would also pose the question: what’s potentially positive about plasticized sexuality? Can’t we see this sort of sexuality as liberating because it’s non-reproductive? It makes sexuality a pleasurable end in and of itself (think dildos, vibrators - all those plastic sex toys that cater to and worship one’s sexual pleasure). So there’s a number of interesting ways to think about how Gaga presents the sexual being, and while Paglia may be right in her diagnosis of Gaga’s sexuality, I disagree with her assessment of it.

Lesley Kinzel: I wholeheartedly agree with the points you both raise above. Still and all, my kneejerk response to this quote when I initially read it was, “...and who made Camille Paglia the supreme arbiter of what counts as sexy?”

In the same section, Paglia also calls Gaga’s brand of sex “clinical and antiseptic,” and to some extent I can get with her there. However, to argue, as Paglia does, that this is somehow deviant from mainstream sex seems incredulous. Contemporary sex involves such inventions as Real Dolls, and the sex-as-concept that Gaga (and most of us in our thirties as well!) have grown up with has always been couched in terms of “safety” and barriers and latex and prevention. A “clinical and antiseptic” approach to sex seems understandable enough to a generation who know the experience of an HIV test, or a Hep B vaccine. I reckon our contemporary culture of sex has been infused through and through with these ideas, and Gaga is simply turning up the volume on that.


---
Dear Readers,
We'd love for you to join this conversation, and tell us your thoughts on the various issues we discuss. Or: give us your definition of "Gaga's Feminism" in 50 words or less!
Cheers, 
Gaga Stigmata


Author Bios:

Kate Durbin: Kate Durbin is an L.A.-based writer and performance artist. She is the author of the poetry collections The Ravenous Audience (Akashic Books, 2009) and, with Amaranth Borsuk, Excess Exhibit, forthcoming from ZG Press. She has written several chapbooks including Fragments Found in a 1937 Aviator's Boot (Dancing Girl Press, 2009), FASHIONWHORE (Legacy Pictures, 2010), and Kept Women, forthcoming from Insert Press. She writes about celebrity style at Hollywood.com and teaches courses on writing and monster theory at Whittier College.

Lesley Kinzel: Lesley Kinzel is a working activist and recovering scholar, both in the realm of gender and body politics, with a healthy side portion of media criticism and popular culture. She has been engaging with fat activism in particular and social justice politics in general for the better part of a decade, and her efforts to talk about fat really loudly with as many people as possible have included writing for venues as diverse as Newsweek, Marie Claire, and Geez. Lesley is currently writing her first book -- on being a radical fatass -- for The Feminist Press, and it is due to hit shelves in early 2012. She blogs at Fatshionista.com.

Meghan Vicks: Meghan Vicks is a doctoral student of Comparative Literature, currently writing her dissertation Narratives of Zero: Writing Upon Nothing in Modern and Postmodern Literature. In addition, she holds a graduate certificate in Women and Gender Studies, and has presented her work at a number of academic conferences on feminist issues, including Kathy Acker’s writings and abortive feminine identity, Boris Pasternak’s bisexual aesthetics, Toni Morrison’s racial and feminine performativity, and the cultural politics of Russian cyber-brides. She has taught various Humanities courses at the University of Colorado, and blogs at Only Words To Play With.

Compare hotel prices and find the best deal - HotelsCombined.com
Compare hotel prices and find the best deal - HotelsCombined.com
Twitter Delicious Facebook Digg Stumbleupon Favorites More